Inside the Secret Facebook Group Where Women Review Men They've Dated

There aren’t enough good single men left on the streets of New York City. At least, that’s what everyone tells us. When Deanna* moved to the city in late 2021 it was her turn to check if there was any truth to the assertion. Being single since her long-time boyfriend separated from her via Snapchat, Deanna joined Hinge and Tinder. At the same time that a private group on Facebook named Is we Dating the Same Guy NYC was announced as the recommended follow. The group included a strict prescreening survey as well as community guidelines which acted as a barrier to entry. It had four-and-a-half million members strong. Deanna was interested and so she joined.

The community

The community-which began with the sole intention to assist women in determining whether their loved ones were seeing other people – was launched in the month of March 2022. The majority of major US city is home to a similar group and the rules for all are simple: Everyone can write anonymously, without doxxing or posting sensitive information or in any way screenshots leave the group. There is no bullying, no victim blaming or hate speech. Never reveal to a man that he’s been added to the group. In the wake from West Elm Caleb, a man who many women in New York shared negative dating experiences and linked the dots on the internet, it appeared that a lot of women were looking for a method of sifting out other people who were like him.Read here https://datingfortodaysman.com/ At our site According to one TikTok user said in the moment This is why we need an app where we can leave reviews of guys we’ve dated on Hinge.

It’s a lot like the way this group was when Deanna joined. Each time, Are We Dating the Same Guy serves as a space for women looking for advice on their relationship or advise men whom they’ve experienced bad dating experiences. Loyalty-testing long-term boyfriends-that is how they send other females to try and lure them onto social media, has also become a norm. It’s not difficult for a person to fall into a hole of screenshots Hinge profiles, tales of hookups gone wrong, and memes that discuss the problems of modern-day dating. Some of the most popular posts consist of photos of a guy with his initials, requesting whether anyone has ever matched or dated the person in question. The emojis in red are a common appearance on sporadic but alarming posts warning the group of an ex or a bad experience frequently accompanied by a downward arrow and the depressing warning words See comments for more info.

Dating online has taken over our chances in recent times, with one recent study finding that almost 39% of heterosexual couples met their spouse online. Therefore, it is only natural that the romance element that involves social interaction will change in the digital age. Instead of chatting with small groups of acquaintances over a drink or venting with coworkers, we are now seeking the counsel of 433,000 women who have had similar, and sometimes, the exact same-experiences.

It’s demystified this idea that dating is easier for some women than it is for others, says Ellie * another group member. Not to suggest there’s no benefits however, it was beneficial for myself in terms of clarifying my perspective on dating. It’s not a competition for women with each other, however it is it is holding men to a higher standards than what I was used to before.

It’s not lost on me, however, that some of the behavior that is facilitated and encouraged in Are We the Dating the Same Guy would be an issue if displayed by potential partners. Photos, photos of private conversations, and screenshots that are posted with no consent or knowledge are all over the internet. Users search through social media profiles almost on a daily basis. It doesn’t take long for a potential date to be taken off the table. Though Deanna enjoys being a part group, she has reservations. Sometimes you see people posting ‘If he wanted to, he would’ about paying for things or picking you up in an Uber, she adds. But I think you are faced with the issue of it’s an echo chamber of men have kept pushing us for so long, we’re ready to give it back.

We are still an age of patriarchy

We’re still living in a patriarchal society-so until we’re truly equal those online interactions could be different in their impact based on the backgrounds of each individual. Still, can a group of this kind really offer committed to empowering itself on one side of the coin, and morally reprehensible and inhumane on the other? Are We All Dating the Same Guy? Hyperlocal and social, only beneficial for those who live and date in the city where the group is based in. The women and men they post about can be your neighbor or coworker, friend, relative, or perhaps your most latest Hinge match. Yet, there’s a sense of depersonalization that is a result of operating on the internet, which makes it feel like it’s a game. It’s no stretch to say that this could be a criticism for the participants in both groups. This is particularly true when the details of private conversations, personal interactions as well as photos can be shared without prior consent or knowledge, but often to provide entertainment.